Debt Voyeurs

July 18, 1999 |
Click here to read this full article.

When it comes to living large on pilfered cash, Martin Frankel -- who is accused of making off with $335 million -- deserves all the attention he has been getting. Here was a guy nervy enough to make a to-do list on which item one was launder money. A guy who secured the use of the Vatican's bank account for his financial chicanery. An essentially geeky guy, by all accounts, whose tastes in spending ran to satellite dishes, computer terminals, bondage videos and bodacious female "retainers." (Yeah, baby!) Yet Frankel's saga of economic malfeasance hasn't held my attention the way the saga of Leonard and Elfreda Massie did.

Now the Massies were no Martin Frankels. They were debtors, not swindlers. Their tastes were bourgeois. But like Frankel, they, too were creatures of this economic moment: outsize spendthrifts who hid in plain sight amid the countless other cases of what the economist Robert H. Frank calls "luxury fever."

Working as public-school administrators (Elfreda Massie was the leading candidate for superintendent of schools in affluent Montgomery County, Md.), the couple earned a total of $180,000 a year and lived in a $350,000 home. Alas, the Massies had 24 credit cards, and they liked to use them. When they finally filed for bankruptcy, they were more than $800,000 in the red, with $10 in cash and no savings. Of the couple's chronic overspending, Elfreda Massie said, "In hindsight, it seems like a poor decision."

I first read about the Massies just after looking over my own latest credit-card bill -- and a sobering little document it was. Just how many natural-fiber bedsheets did I really have to own, anyway? And what about those weeks of fines on a video we'd rented but never watched? The Massies' spending behavior was remote from mine, but not alien. They embodied all the complacency that comes of living among the stock-owning, S.U.V.-driving classes. I imagined them chatting with their neighbors -- Hey, how was Aruba? -- tossing collection notices into a bottom drawer, perhaps figuring that there was always the escape hatch of bankruptcy.

And the Massies' story is only one among many. Just as we are seeing a proliferation of stories about economic envy, so too are we seeing a proliferation of stories like theirs that pique the delicious theme of economic Schadenfreude. Reporting about them almost constitutes a genre unto itself -- a kind of pornography of debt in which "the urge to splurge," as U.S. News puts it, is explored in all its lascivious and compromising detail.

In a way, there is nothing surprising about the appetite for such accounts. Personal bankruptcies have doubled over the last decade, to about 1.4 million annually, according to the most recent figures. (To help stem this tide, Congress has recently taken up legislation to make it harder for people to declare bankruptcy -- a control that was eagerly advocated by the credit industry.) The average American household has 11 credit cards and carries $7,000 in debt on them. Fewer than half of all cardholders pay their bills in full each month. And on and on. Naturally a nation of debtors wants to read how other people, doing what the rest of us do only more so, finally go off the rails.

True, the fascination with fortunes seized and squandered is not new. "In this republican country, amid the fluctuating waves of our social life," Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote, "somebody is always at the drowning-point." But at a Gold Rush moment like this one, when new riches seem easy to procure yet hard to delineate, curiosity about other people's money becomes simply irresistible. And debt itself takes on an airy-fairy aspect: like this strange new wealth that so few of us understand, it exists only on paper -- at least till the credit agents start calling.

Paradoxically, the many articles about debt (often unconvincingly packaged as helpful service pieces) end up confirming our own profligacy. Sure we just ordered $250 worth of gourmet kitchenware, but hey, at least it wasn't $15,000 in "knickknacks and household furnishings from places like the Christmas Tree Shop," the particular indulgence of a credit-card debtor recently featured in The Boston Globe.

The best debt porn relies on a first-person voice -- Credit Cards Ruined My Life" (Teen magazine) or "Confessions of a Credit Card Queen" (Essence) -- and a familiar narrative arc: temptation leads to excess leads to a downward spiral of spending, evoked for our disapproving pleasure. Then -- wham -- rock bottom: she breaks down while forging a credit-card application; he realizes he has never opened half his purchases. The language of addiction and recovery kicks in: they must acknowledge they have a problem, then submit to counseling, prayer and support groups. Reform, however, does not mean abstinence -- this is the 90's -- but instead higher-level consumption. To the self-professed credit-card queen in Essence, the worst thing about her habit was sacrificing "long-term financial goals." "I had become so passive about my finances that I believed things like owning a home, buying a new car and taking fancy vacations were dreams I'd never fulfill. Silly me."

Ultimately, credit confessionals give us a way of working through our fears of a financial crash, which, in the current economy, are always present, often repressed. Credit-card bingers are not a new phenomenon, but the way their fevered spending seems to mirror the economy as a whole is. Stories of this genre --parables of overconfident overspending, comeuppance and a happy righting of the debtor's course -- serve as metaphors for our overall financial health that are bracing but not truly disturbing. They offer us an occasion to worry about financial stability without worrying about financial inequality. They lend middle- and upper-middle-class consumers a smug sense of maturity and responsibility. They don't tax our powers of empathy very much. They are the hard-luck stories of the century's end, and they really aren't so hard at all.


"Forgiving Debt: How To"

1. We came to believe we were powerless over debt -- that our lives had become unmanageable.
2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.
3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.
4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
5. Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of ourwrongs.
6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed and became willing to make amends to them all.
9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.
10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.
11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.
12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to compulsive debtors, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.